| Name | High School | College | Drafted By | Level |
| Kevin Arico | Hunterdon Central HS | University of Virginia | Minnesota Twins | |
| Bobby Abreu | Piscataway HS | Seton Hall University | | |
| Scott Allan | Immaculata HS | Monclair State University | | |
| Matt Alvarez | Princeton HS | Boston College | | |
| Craig Anderson | Passaic Valley HS | Brookdale CC | | |
| Dan Angelo | Holy Cross | St. Johns University | | |
| Brett Arnold | Cherokee HS | Elon University | | |
| DJ Anderson | Delbarton HS | Rutgers University | | |
| Tom Augustyniak | Immaculata HS | Monmouth University | | |
| Jim Birmingham | Overbrook HS | Coastal Carolina | Washington Nationals | |
| Sean Black | Lenape HS | Seton Hall University | Washington Nationals | |
| Andrew Baxter | The Hun School | Drew University | | |
| Willie Beard | Spotswood HS | Rutgers University | | |
| Joe Bellini | Delbarton HS | Lehigh University | | |
| Matt Bernhardt | Immaculata HS | Navy | | |
| Pat Biserta | Pt. Pleasant Boro | Rutgers University | | |
| Jeff Bland | Immaculata HS | US Naval Academy | | |
| Brandon Boykin | Don Bosco Prep | Rutgers University | | |
| Steven Brooks | Seton Hall Prep | Wake Forest University | | |
| Eddie Brown | St. Joes Metutchen | Seton Hall University | | |
| AJ Casario | Overbrook HS | University of Maryland | L.A. Dodgers | |
| Brian Caballero | Immaculata HS | Drexel University | | |
| Dylan Cacciola | Westwood HS | University of West Virginia | | |
| David Caffrey | Delbarton HS | Rutgers University | | |
| Drew Campbell | Hillsborough HS | Salisbury State University | | |
| Keith Carman | Lenape HS | Farliegh Dickinson University | | |
| Tommy Ciccarone | Immaculata HS | Marist College | | |
| Kyle Cichy | St. Augustine Prep | West Carolina University | | |
| Jamie Colt | Immaculata HS | Moravian College | | |
| Nick Corrado | Gloucester Catholic | Lehigh University | | |
| Jeff Couch | Red Bank Catholic | Quinnipiac University | | |
| Chas Crane | Immaculata HS | Winthrop University | | |
| John Curreiri | North Hunterdon HS | University of Rhode Island | | |
