| Name | High School | College | Drafted By | Level |
| Mike Dennhardt | Don Bosco Prep | Boston College | Seattle Mariners | |
| Anthony DeSclafani | Colts Neck HS | University of Florida | Boston Red Sox | |
| Vin Difazio | Pennington Prep | University of Alabama | Baltimore Orioles | |
| Steven D'Angelo | Union Catholic | Pace University | | |
| Kyle Davis | Ewing HS | University of Delaware | | |
| Dan DeGeorge | Delbarton HS | Princeton University | | |
| Evan Deluca | Immaculata HS | San Diego University | | |
| Gary DerHagopian | Lenape HS | Siena College | | |
| Gregory Desantis | Bridgewater HS | Long Island University | | |
| Dan DiBartulomeo | Holy Spirit | University of West Virginia | | |
| James Dinizo | Scotch Plains HS | University of Northern Iowa | | |
| Joe Doerrer | Raritan HS | Caldwell College | | |
| James Dolbier | North Hunterdon HS | Villanova University | | |
| Ryan Doty | St. John Vianney | Montclair State University | | |
| Eric Eden | Hillsborough HS | Florida CC at Jacksonville | | |
| Kevin Ernst | Manalapan HS | Rider University | | |
| Mike Esola | Freehold HS | Naval Academy | | |
| Drew Fitz-Maurice | Council Rock-North | Winthrop University | | |
| Dan Fitzsimmons | Hunterdon Central HS | Princeton University | | |
| Ben Flanary | Cherokee HS | Temple University | | |
| Angel Flores | Vineland HS | Lewisburg CC | | |
| Frank Florio | Immaculata HS | Stetson University | | |
| Greg Folgia | Christopher Dock (PA) | University of Missouri | | |
| Shane Fox | Bishop Eustace Prep | Fordham University | | |
