| Name | High School | College | Drafted By | Level |
| Chris Jenkins | Westfield HS | Stanford University | | |
| Ryan Kalish | Red Bank Catholic | University of Virginia | Boston Red Sox | |
| Michael Kaminski | Somerville HS | Long Island University | | |
| Chris Kievit | Don Bosco Prep | Long Island University | | |
| Ryan King | Montgomery HS | Siena College | | |
| Matt Kirchner | Haddonfield | Elon University | | |
| Colin Kish | Germantown Academy (PA) | Florida Southern University | | |
| Adam Kissinger | Egg Harbor Township | Philadelphia College of Science | | |
| Brett Koehler | Vorhees HS | William & Mary University | | |
| Chris Koken | Immaculata HS | UMBC | | |
| Nick Koken | Immaculata HS | George Washington University | | |
| Andrew Kolmar | Delbarton HS | Yale University | | |
| Henry Knabe | Immaculata HS | Temple University | | |
| Brian Komorowski | Voorhees HS | Fairleigh Dickinson University | | |
| Robert Kral | Randolph HS | College of Charleston | | |
| Chris Kraus | North Hunterdon HS | Temple University | | |
| John Kruse | Wayne Valley HS | Montclair State University | | |
| Rob Kumbotovic | Hillsborough HS | Hofstra University | | |
| Matt Lemke | Immaculata HS | Pitt JC | | |
| Charlie Law | Mainland HS | Rutgers University | Philadelphia Phillies
| |
| Clint Lawyer | Clearview HS | Rider University | | |
| Ryan Levine | St. Joe's Montvale | University of Virginia | | |
| Adam Links | Central Bucks East HS | West Virginia University | | |
| Alex Longo | Ramapo | Ramapo College | | |
| Justin Lorentzen | Bridgewater HS | Montclair State University | | |
| John Lucas | Hacketstown HS | Iona College | | |
| Ben Luderer | Don Bosco Prep | Marist College |
| |
