| Name | High School | College | Drafted By | Level |
| Matt Marquis | Immaculata HS | Vanderbilt University | Boston Red Sox | |
| Jaren Matthews | Don Bosco Prep | Rutgers University | Boston Red Sox | |
| Kevin Mager | Middletown HS | University of Maine | | |
| Tom Malafronte | Somerville HS | Rutgers University | | |
| Matt Marrotta | Don Bosco Prep | NJIT | | |
| Bryce Martel | Hunterdon Central HS | St. Joes University | | |
| B.J. Martin | Manalapan HA | St. John's University | | |
| Mickey Martin | Immaculata HS | Princeton University | | |
| Sean McKeown | Immaculata HS | Marist College | | |
| Kenneth Meerendonk | Vernon Twsp. HS | Stevens Tech. | | |
| Juan Mejia | St. Augustine Prep | Caldwell College | | |
| Jeff Mellilo | North Hunterdon HS | Rutgers University | | |
| Michael Mellilo | North Hunterdon HS | Elon University | | |
| David Milanese | St. Joe's Metuchen | Naval Academy | | |
| Brooks Miller | Governor Livingston | St. Joseph's University | | |
| Tim Miller | Mendham HS | Moravian College | | |
| Jon Mish | Bridgewater HS | The College of New Jersey | | |
| Matt Moceri | Camden Catholic | Burlington CC | | |
| Chris Monaco | Bishop Eustace Prep | St. Joseph's University | | |
| Patrick Monaghan | Eastern HS | St. Joseph's University | | |
| Ken Monteith | Morristown Beard | Winthrop University | | |
| Logan Morello | Immaculata HS | Polk CC | | |
| Josh Morrison | Immaculata HS | Montclair State University | | |
| Kyle Morrison | Immaculata HS | Wagner College | | |
| Sean Munley | The Hun School | Wheaton College | | |
| Jeff Murdza | Lawrenceville Prep | Navy | | |
| Billy Murphy | Roselle Catholic | Rutgers University | | |
| Mike Murray | Westfield HS | Wake Forest University | | |
| Matt Neiber | Immaculata HS | Drexel University | | |
| Michael Nemeth | Warren Hills HS | University of Connecticut | | |
| Michael Newland | Delaware Valley HS | DeSales University | | |
| Frank Nicolosi | Winslow Township | Dominican University | | |
| Eric Nodes | North Hunterdon HS | Florida Atlantic University | | |
| Nick Nolan | Roselle Catholic | Rutgers University | | |
| Justin Nusblatt | Princeton Day | Fairfield University | | |
| Sean O'Hare | Seton Hall Prep | St. Johns University | | |
| Michael O'Keeffe | Don Bosco Prep | University of Delaware | | |
| Sean Olson | St. Augustine Prep | Rider University | | |
| Joey O'Malley | Moorestown HS | East Carolina University | | |
| Kyle Orensky | McKean HS (DE) | University of Delaware | | |
| Dewey Oriente | Bishop Eustace Prep | Villanova University | | |
| Matthew Owens | St. Joe's Metuchen | Long Island University | | |
