| Name | High School | College | Drafted By | Level |
| Eric Pfisterer | Don Bosco Prep | Duke University | Cincinnatti Reds | |
| Jeff Panzarella | Immaculata HS | Monmouth University | | |
| Nick Panzarella | Immaculata HS | Hofstra University | | |
| Michael Parenti | Immaculata HS | Fairleigh Dickinson University | | |
| Nick Pecora | Immaculata HS | Wheaton College | | |
| Joe Perez | Absegami | Gloucester CC | | |
| Chris Petrosini | Immaculata HS | Citadel | | |
| Michael Plakis | Bishop Eustace Prep | St. Joseph's University | | |
| Matt Potts | Camden Catholic | Wagner College | | |
| Darren Poherence | Immaculata HS | St. John's University | | |
| Alex Pracher | Cherokee HS | Stanford University | | |
| Andrew Priece | Bridgewater HS | College of New Jersey | | |
| Reid Pulford | Shawnee HS | Seton Hall University | | |
| David Putman | The Hun School | Duke University | | |
| Brad Raynor | Lawrenceville Prep | University of North Carolina-Greensboro | | |
| Rob Restaino | Immaculata HS | Lafayette College | | |
| Keith Reynolds | Camden Catholic | Lewisburg College | | |
| Billy Rice | Washington Twsp | University of Maryland | | |
| Jake Rifkin | West Depford HS | Marist College | | |
| Chris Rini | Immaculata HS | Rutgers University | | |
| Chris Roach | Hacketstown HS | Seton Hall University | | |
| Nate Roe | Seton Hall Prep | Brookdale CC | | |
| Jamie Rosenkranz | Ocean Twsp | Monmouth University | | |
| Brett Rossi | Hunterdon Central HS | Barry University | | |
| AJ Rusbarsky | Colts Neck HS | Seton Hall University | | |
| Shawn Sanford | Cinnaminson HS | University of South Florida | Texas Rangers | |
| Matt Szczur | Lower Cape May | Villanova University | L.A. Dodgers | |
| Stephen Sanguiliano | Hunterdon Central HS | Monmouth University | | |
| Jesse Santo | Passaic Valley HS | Polk CC (Florida) | | |
| Dan Sasso | Bordentown HS | Rider University | | |
| Brian Scanlon | The Hun School | Babson College | | |
| John Schoberl | Immaculata HS | Naval Academy | | |
| Eddie Schultz | Immaculata HS | St. John's University | | |
| Michael Schwartz | Lenape HS | Keystone University | | |
| Brian Seres | South Amboy HS | Brookdale CC | | |
| Greg Sherry | Delbarton HS | University of Notre Dame | | |
| DJ Stinsman | Egg Harbor Township | Dominican University | | |
| Will Stratton | Tower Hill | Yale University | | |
| Nick Stravakis | Immaculata HS | Xavier University | | |
