| Name | High School | College | Drafted By | Level |
| Chris Berroa | Pennasauken HS | Chipola JC | NY Mets | Minors |
| Casey Cahill | Immaculata HS | East Carolina University | Baltimore Orioles | Minors |
| Kevin Cust | Immaculata HS | St. John's University | Atlanta Braves | Minors |
| Mike Cust | Immaculata HS | Seton Hall University | St. Louis Cardinals | Minors |
| Pete Duda | St. Peters Prep | Stanford University | Arizona D-Backs | Minors |
| Tim Fedroff | Hillsborough HS | University of North Carolina | Cleveland Indians | Minors |
| Joe Florio | Blair Academy | University of Virginia | Oakland A's | Minors |
| Jonathan George | Camden Catholic | University of Arkansas | Cincinnatti Reds | Minors |
| Steve Gilman | North Hunterdon HS | Yale University | Detroit Tigers | Minors |
| Tony Gsell | Immaculata HS | Old Dominion University | Chicago Cubs | Minors |
| Kyle Higgins | Watchung Hills HS | Monmouth University | Texas Rangers | Minors |
| David Housel | Mendham HS | Morris County College | New York Mets | Minors |
| Jon Hutton | North Plainfield HS | Miami-Dade JC | Florida Marlins | Minors |
| Cole Kimball | Phillipsburg HS | Centenary College | Washington Nationals | Minors |
| Jason Knapp | North Hunterdon HS | University of North Carolina | Philadelphia Phillies | Minors |
| Kevin Kotch | Middlesex HS | Indian River CC | Baltimore Orioles | Minors |
| Tim Lemke | Immaculata HS | University of Alabama | Atlanta Braves | Minors |
| Bill Malloy | Immaculata HS | Rutgers University | SF Giants | Minors |
| Joe Martinez | Seton Hall Prep | Boston College | Pittsburgh Pirates | Minors |
| Quinton Miller | Shawnee HS | University of North Carolina | Pittsburgh Pirates | Minors |
| Kevin Mulvey | Bishop Ahr | Villanova University | St. Louis Cardinals | Minors |
| Tim Pahuta | Hunterdon Central HS | Seton Hall University | Washington Nationals | Minors |
| Matt Rigoli | Parsippany | Lamoyne College | St. Louis Cardinals | Minors |
| Billy Rowell | Bishop Eustice | University of Alabama | Baltimore Orioles | Minors |
| Tim Sabo | Don Bosco Prep | Seton Hall University | Cleveland Indians | Minors |
| Tim Stringer | North Hunterdon HS | Montclair State University | River City Rascals (IND) | Minors |
| Nick Tyson | Timber Creek HS | Chipola JC | Milwaukee Brewers | Minors |
